Duty to God

Scouting can change without abandoning the central intention of its existence. Our own core values compel us to extend the hand of friendship consistent with our tradition of brotherhood. The movement must, as America itself, grow more tolerant and more inclusive; more willing to accept that diversity can be enriching and not diluting. Our continuing strength is in the realization that change, like growth is inevitable. The Oath and Law where composed upon the founding of the movement in 1910 reflecting Judeo-Christian beliefs; a perfectly natural and acceptable practice for the time.

While the majority of Americans still practice monotheistic faiths an increasing number have embraced other belief systems. What does it mean when we pledge our duty to God in the Scout Oath?

Ultimately the answer must lie within the individual according to their conscience and tradition.

Scouting does not advocate a specific form of religious thought or organization. We offer no standard test of adherence to this part of the Oath; it is incumbent on the individual to observe his duty as he interprets.

Scouting recognizes three religious emblems from groups that do not believe in the single personal God that the Oath implies; Buddhist – Sangha: The Buddha, while a central figure of the religion, is not thought of as God but as a spiritually enlightened individual.

Adherents accept that they can attain enlightenment on the same level as the Buddha.

Hindu – Karma: “Unity in the diverse plan of nature” is recognized in the Hindu faith. Just as people tailor clothes to fit their needs, Hindus have different gods and goddesses for their religious needs.

Unitarians – Religion in life: Some Unitarian Universalists are non theists and do not find language about God useful.

These represent only the officially recognized awards; what of Scouts who profess Shintoism, Confucianism, Wicca, and other faiths? In the light of this why do we not accept atheists and agnostics?

Scouting can accommodate all who share the values of moral leadership and personal development no matter what their internal motivation. Our national constitution tolerates all faiths equally. This tolerance draws people from every corner of the world to share in our great, and many would say, God-given abundance. We have benefited from the many ideologies and systems of thought that have melded into our National culture.

Scouting has a great opportunity in a changing world to demonstrating friendship, tolerance and the ability to accept change.